Riddle Me Piss

Riddle Me Piss is a segment where the McElroys read riddles off of the internet (mostly riddles.com). The riddles are generally unsolvable, but earnest.

Justin first discovered riddles.com in Episode 418 and in the next episode, Griffin named it. Since then, Travis has taken over hosting it as an infrequent segment, most often during live shows.

In Episode 458, Travis suggested that everyone hates the segment, but Justin countered, saying that "Riddle Me Piss has a 100% success rate... it's just harder for you to do, so you don't."