Under the Table and Phishing is a segment created by Travis, in which he reads off song lyrics and quizzes his brothers on whether the lyrics were written by Dave Matthews Band or Phish.
For Episode 545, Travis decided that Phish lyrics weren't horny enough to blend in with Dave Matthews Band, so Phish was replaced by John Mayer, turning the quiz into "Your Body is a Satellite."
A similar ad-hoc quiz was performed in Episode 196, in which Justin quizzed his brothers on whether song lyrics came from Jimmy Buffett or Kenny Chesney. Even earlier than that, Phish was brought up when responding to a listener question in Episode 112 that asked about Dave Matthews Band.
| My Brother, My Brother and Me | |
|---|---|
| MBMBaM Segments | |
|---|---|
| Current | |
| Historic | |
| Endings | |
| Other | |